Coping With A WHS Hard Disk Failure
Everton | Mar 22, 2008 | Comments 17
I haven’t written a lot of posts this week as I’ve spent most of the week trying to recover files from one of the hard drives in my Windows Home Server that has stopped working. I have several disks in my WHS machine, and if any of the other drives had failed I wouldn’t have cared so much, but this drive just happened to be the one with all my photos (and some music) on it which obviously can’t be replaced and are priceless to me.
The WHS box has been telling me intermittently that the drive has been failing for a few weeks now, but the messages always went away, so I just ignored them. When my WHS box started transferring files really slowly rather than attributing this to the earlier warnings, I decided it was a software rather than a hardware problem and rebuilt the whole machine. This involved moving all my files temporarily from the WHS machine to my other PCs, before moving them back. If only I’d removed the faulty drive before moving my files back, as it died before the Folder Duplication had finished…… :-( My JungleDisk service wasn’t of much use, as it had so far only backed up around 50% of my music and none of my photos because of my slow upload speed.
Anyway, I’ve managed to recover manually about 50% of my photos and around 95% of my music by connecting the drive to my main PC and accessing the hidden shared folders (DE/Shares) on the drive that WHS uses. However, my machine won’t boot anymore with the disk attached, so I can’t use this method to recover the remaining files.
I took the drive down to Tottenham Court Road yesterday to see if I could pay someone to recover the remaining files. I really wasn’t impressed with the responses I was getting, particularly as I felt I was going to pay someone with no more technical knowledge than me to perform the same methods I’d already tried.
One very friendly tech at YoYOtech, which is where I go for sensible advice on systems, suggested I boot my machine with a Linux CD which would allow me to continue searching the failed Hard Drive for files. It’s going to be an interesting experience for me as you may find this amazing to learn, but I’ve never used linux before! I’ll let you know how I get on.
Anyone got any suggestions as to which version I should try first?
Related Posts
- Windows Home Server Deleted My Files!
- Feedback: How Are You Coping With High Petroleum Prices?
- Should I Buy A HP MediaSmart Server?
- WebGuide Addon Available For Windows Home Server
- Remove Duplicate Files With DoubleKiller
- Now My Main PC Has Died As Well!
- Pixelotto Looks Like It’s Going To Be A Failure – Only 16K Pixels Sold Last 7 Days
Filed Under: Everton
Bookmark & Share
About the Author: Everton is based in London and has worked in the internet and mobile space for over ten years now, and before that worked in corporate strategy and consulting. He has a degree in Economics from Cambridge University, and currently runs the Portal and online operations for one of the largest ISPs in the UK.
He also writes for Windows 8 News, Windows 8 News and One Tip A Day.
Comments (17)
Trackbacks/Pingbacks
- Now My Main PC Has Died As Well! | Connected Internet
- Blog statistics from Feb 25th 2008 till date - Mobile J Games





@everton Ah I see.. I guess I can only say sorry for your loss.
Everton
I remembered I saw this tip, not sure of if it will help and there are also some other suggestions in the comments.
http://digg.com/hardware/Putting_your_Dead_Hard_Drive_in_the_Freezer_may_Get_it_working_again
Barry Cleave
http://proreviewer.com
PS Your “Split” comments isn’t working for me in Firefox or IEexplorer. Can only see the latest comments in Firefox and they don’t even show (can’t see the text but can see the avatars) in IEex. Clicking on the page number or All just sends me back to your homepage.
PPS Just gone back to the article from the homepage in IEex and all the comments are listed but can’t see the text, just a bullet point to the left and avatar to the right.
Sorry for losing the photos & music files respectively.
Your best bet is TestDisk
http://www.cgsecurity.org/wiki/TestDisk
The same thing has happend to me in a way… but i never got the warnning you seem to of had. one day i booted into my vista comp only to see a nice red WSH logo… after hovering over it, the message read. SeagateSA11013 hass failed and needs to be replaced. so i thought well thats not to bad as i have 3 of the same 500gb disks in there so redundancy is fine. but it looks like there are mayor file conflicks which arnt helping me right now. it seems that the drive will only work for about 10-15 mins after booting, then windows says its failed. but if i try and remove the drive before it fails to sort out all the conflicks. the drive fails around half way though the removal wizard and i’m back to the start again. i think i might have to keep trying or even just accpect the conflicks….. any ways in a way its good reading that its not just me here. great post. cheers
Will
Devon
UK
Sorry to hear about your troubles – I hope you have more success than me
Problem sorted, I tryed frezzing the drive which gave the drive long enugh for the data to be recoved. whohoo and WHS is happy again now. Cheers Everton